The Mermaid & The Alligator

729 Truman Avenue, Downtown Key West, Key West, United States - Short walk to Duval Street
9.3/10 · 159 reviews

Offering a swimming pool, the 3-star smoke-free The Mermaid & The Alligator Key West hotel is situated in the Downtown Key West district, 1.1 miles from the Harry S. Truman Little White House. Featuring a storage for belongings, the hotel is located not far from the even Southernmost Point.

Location

This Key West hotel has a prime location about a 25-minute walk from Smathers Beach. US 1 Mile Marker 0 is in proximity to Mermaid & The Alligator. The nearby shopping sights include the waterfront Mallory Square, which is 1.2 miles away. The nearest bus stop is Truman Avenue & Simonton Street approximately 5 minutes' drive away.

Food & Drinks

Those staying at this accommodation can sit down to a free breakfast. Better Than Sex is 0.2 miles from the Key West hotel.

Leisure & Activities

Mermaid & The Alligator Key West features a spa with Jacuzzis and a hot tub.

Why choose The Mermaid & The Alligator Key West

Select room

  • Lush tropical gardens with exotic birds

  • Heated plunge pool for relaxation

  • Luxurious suites with unique decor

  • Complimentary fresh breakfast daily

Main amenities

  • Wi-Fi

  • Swimming Pool

  • Spa and relaxation

  • Air conditioning

  • No pets allowed

General
  • Wi-Fi
  • Swimming Pool
  • Spa and relaxation
  • Air conditioning
  • No pets allowed
1/31

Internet

  • Wi-Fi

Parking options

  • Parking

Property services

  • Safe deposit box
  • VIP check-in/ -out
  • Concierge desk
  • Luggage storage
  • Housekeeping

Dining options

  • Outdoor dining area

Business facilities

  • Fax/Photocopying

For kids

  • Adults only
  • Board games

Recreation

  • Outdoor swimming pool
  • Beach umbrellas
  • Sun loungers
  • Sun terrace
  • Garden area
  • Leisure/ TV room
  • Jacuzzi

In the rooms

  • Air conditioning
  • Heating
  • Sitting area
  • Patio
  • Garden furniture
  • Ironing facilities

In the bathroom

  • Free toiletries

Devices

  • AM/FM alarm clock

Design

  • Carpeted floor

General facilities

  • No smoking on site
  • Smoke detectors
  • Fire extinguishers
  • Key access

Pets

  • No pets allowed

Important information

Check-in:
from 15:00 until 23:59
Check-out:
until 11:00
  • Children and extra beds
  • There are no cribs provided in a room.

Enter dates to see availability

From USD 360 per night
Check-in 2 Jun 2026
Check-out 3 Jun 2026
Guests 2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0
All rates verified
How we verified prices Our team regularly checks prices to make sure you see the lowest available rates. We compare them with hotel prices and other providers. If discounts or promotions appear, prices on our site are updated accordingly.

Rooms

Photos of The Mermaid & The Alligator Key West

The Mermaid & The Alligator 1/100
The Mermaid & The Alligator
The Mermaid & The Alligator
The Mermaid & The Alligator
The Mermaid & The Alligator

The Mermaid & The Alligator Key West

Hotel offering a luxurious tropical oasis in Key West

Location of The Mermaid & The Alligator Key West

729 Truman Avenue, Downtown Key West, Key West, United States

 -  Short walk to Duval Street
Attractions
Great restaurants
Transportation

Places nearby

    Guest reviews of The Mermaid & The Alligator Key West

    9.3 Superb
    159 reviews

    Write a review

    When did you travel?

    Your rating point

    Very bad
    Excellent

    Your details

    Where are you from?
    Thank you! Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your review will be published shortly.

    Review has not been sent.

    Please try again.

    Popular hotels in Key West

    Find your perfect hotel stay today

    From USD 364

    The Garden House Hotel Key West
    Key West, 329 Elizabeth St, Key West, United States

    The Garden House Hotel Key West, located just 350 metres from Nancy Forrester's Secret Garden and just a 5-minute walk from the very unusual Key West Cemetery, features a swimming pool for guests to…

    From USD 435

    Key Largo Cottages
    Key Largo, 99306 Overseas Highway, Key Largo, United States

    The 2-star Key Largo Cottages hotel is situated just near the Key Largo and features a sundeck, a picnic area, and a golf course. Offering guided snorkelling trips, this resort is only steps away…

    Mangrove Marina And Resort Aqualodge Houseboats Tavernier
    Tavernier, 200 Florida Ave, Tavernier, United States

    Featuring views of the bay, the 3-star Mangrove Marina And Resort Aqualodge Houseboats Tavernier is located a stone's throw from B&B Tavernier Cinema 5. Staying in one of 15 rooms, guests can enjoy a…

    From USD 304

    Caloosa Cove Resort By Coolvacay Hotel
    Islamorada, 73801 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, United States

    The 3-star Caloosa Cove Resort Islamorada is about 25 minutes' walk from the Craig Key and features a sun terrace with outdoor dining areas.

    From USD 273

    Avalon Bed And Breakfast (Adults Only) Hotel
    Key West, 1317 Duval Street, Key West, United States

    The 3-star Avalon Bed And Breakfast Key West is nestled approximately a 5-minute walk from Southernmost Point of the Continental US Monument and features a swimming pool. The bed & breakfast entices…

    From USD 122

    Snappers Key Largo Hotel
    Key Largo, 139 Seaside Avenue, Key Largo, United States

    Situated in the immediate vicinity of Snappers Key Largo Hotel, guests can reach the Our Beach in no time. The inn offers a car park on site.

    From USD 156

    Key Largo Inn Hotel
    Key Largo, 99202 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, United States

    Key Largo Inn, located a 19-minute walk from the Key Largo, features Wi-Fi throughout the property. There is a pool bar and a swimming pool available on the premises.

    From USD 249

    Yacht Haven Marathon
    Marathon, 5 Sombrero Boulevard, Marathon, United States

    Located 2.2 km from the Turtle Hospital|The Turtle Hospital, the 3-star Yacht Haven Hotel Marathon is merely 7 minutes' walk from Sombrero Reef. There is a terrace fitted with a barbecue grill and…

    From USD 560

    La Mer Hotel & Dewey House (Adults Only) Key West
    Key West, 506 South Street, Key West, United States

    Featuring a restaurant, the exclusive 4-star La Mer Hotel & Dewey House Key West is located a mere 5 minutes on foot from the even Southernmost Point. Thanks to its oceanfront location, the award…

    Popular hotels all over the world

    Find your perfect hotel stay today

    From USD 29

    Mavruka Hotel Oludeniz
    Oludeniz, Belcegiz Mevkii 228 Sk No: 1, Oludeniz, Turkey
    4.0 663 reviews

    From USD 228

    Traveller's Cave Hotel Goreme
    Goreme, Aydinli Mahallesi Gorceli Sokak No:7, Goreme, Turkey

    From USD 177

    Hotel website www.mexicoresorts.org/hotel-hacienda-guadalupe.en.html
    Valle de Guadalupe, Km 81.5 Carretera Tecate - Ensenada, Valle de Guadalupe, Mexico

    From USD 51

    Stay at the Grand Fifty Suites Hotel
    Playa del Carmen, Calle 50 Norte Avenida 1Ra Y 5Ta, Playa del Carmen, Mexico

    From USD 167

    Mansion San Miguel Hotel San Miguel De Allende
    San Miguel de Allende, Huertas 35 / Centro, San Miguel de Allende, Mexico

    From USD 129

    Villa Morena Boutique Hotel Ecoliving Akumal
    Akumal, Rancho San Martin Carretera Cancun-Tulum Km. 256, Akumal, Mexico

    From USD 224

    Hotel Eleuthera Retreat - Private Villa & Cottages On Pink Sand Beachfront
    Palmetto Point, North Shore, Palmetto Point, Bahamas

    From USD 294

    Website: Hotel One On Marlin Resort (Adults Only)
    Turtle Cove, 38 Marlin Street, Po Box 220, Providenciales, Turks & Caicos Islands, Wi, Turtle Cove, Turks And Caicos Islands

    From USD 249

    Club Seabourne Hotel Isla Culebra
    Isla Culebra, Fulladosa Bay, Ensenada Honda, Isla Culebra, Puerto Rico
    4.5 437 reviews
    Currency
    • USD U.S. dollar
    • EUR Euro
    • GBP Pound sterling
    • AUD Australian dollar
    • CAD Canadian dollar
    • BRL Brazilian real
    • CNY Chinese yuan
    • CZK Czech koruna
    • DKK Danish krone
    • HKD Hong Kong dollar
    • ILS Israeli new sheqel
    • JPY Japanese yen
    • MYR Malaysian ringgit
    • NZD New Zealand dollar
    • NOK Norwegian krone
    • PLN Polish zloty
    • RON Romanian leu
    • RUB Russian ruble
    • SAR Saudi riyal
    • SGD Singapore dollar
    • ZAR South African rand
    • KRW South Korean won
    • SEK Swedish krona
    • CHF Swiss franc
    • TRY Turkish lira
    • UAH Ukrainian hryvnia
    • THB Thai baht
    • ARS Argentina, Peso
    Select language
    100% Verified Reviews
    Enter dates to see availability
    From USD 360 per night
    Check-in 2 Jun 2026
    Check-out 3 Jun 2026
    Guests 2 guests

    Adults:

    2

    Children:

    0
    All rates verified
    How we verified prices Our team regularly checks prices to make sure you see the lowest available rates. We compare them with hotel prices and other providers. If discounts or promotions appear, prices on our site are updated accordingly.
    Check-in & out
    2 Jun 2026
    —
    3 Jun 2026
    Guests
    2 guests
    Check availability
    We're here to help
    Hi there! Have a question? Message us—our team is happy to assist.
    Your details:
    Subject:
    Message:
    Thank you for your message. We’ll get back to you shortly!
    Your message was not delivered
    Important information
    The Mermaid & The Alligator
    Check-in:
    from 15:00 until 23:59
    Check-out:
    until 11:00
    • Children and extra beds
    • There are no cribs provided in a room.